AUTHOR GUIDELINES

Reviewer Guidelines

REVIEWER GUIDELINES

REVIEWER GUIDELINES

The African Journal of Economic Transformation and Development (AJETD), published by African Academic Imprint Press (AAIMP), Nigeria, is committed to maintaining the quality and integrity of scholarly publications.

Peer review enables the journal to assess the academic quality, originality, relevance, and methodological soundness of submitted manuscripts. It also provides authors with independent feedback that can help improve their work before publication.

AJETD adopts a double-blind peer-review system, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another. Reviewers are therefore expected to assess manuscripts independently, objectively and constructively.

Accepting a Review Assignment

Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, research experience and familiarity with the subject area of the manuscript.

Before accepting an invitation, reviewers should:

  • Examine the manuscript title and abstract to determine whether the subject falls within their area of expertise.
  • Confirm that they can complete the review within the specified period.
  • Disclose any personal, professional, institutional or financial interest that could affect their impartiality.
  • Decline the assignment if they lack the necessary expertise or cannot provide an independent assessment.

A reviewer who is unable to undertake an assignment should inform the editorial office promptly.

Confidentiality

Manuscripts submitted to AJETD for review are confidential documents. Reviewers must respect the confidentiality of the manuscript and the entire review process.

Reviewers are required to:

  • Keep the manuscript and its contents confidential.
  • Avoid sharing the manuscript with another person without the editor’s permission.
  • Not disclose the identity of the authors or discuss the manuscript with third parties.
  • Do not reproduce, distribute, or use unpublished material from the manuscript for personal or professional purposes.
  • Keep review reports and editorial correspondence confidential.

These obligations remain in force after the review has been completed.

General Principles of Manuscript Assessment

Reviewers should assess manuscripts on their academic merit and relevance to the aims and scope of AJETD. Personal opinions about an author’s background, nationality, gender, institutional affiliation, or other characteristics must not influence the assessment.

In reviewing a manuscript, particular attention should be given to:

  • Originality and contribution to existing knowledge.
  • Clarity of the research problem, objectives and questions.
  • Adequacy of the theoretical and empirical literature.
  • Appropriateness of the research design and methodology.
  • Accuracy of data analysis and interpretation of results.
  • Consistency between the findings, conclusions and recommendations.
  • Relevance of the manuscript to economic transformation and development.
  • Quality of presentation, organisation and referencing.

Reviewers should explain their assessments clearly and identify areas requiring improvement.

Assessment of Manuscripts

All reviewers are required to complete the journal’s official Manuscript Reviewer’s Comments Form. The form provides the framework for assessing the manuscript and submitting recommendations to the editorial team.

The assessment covers the following areas:

  1. Title Suitability

Determine whether the title adequately represents the subject and content of the manuscript. Where necessary, suggest a more appropriate title.

  1. Introduction

Assess whether the opening paragraph provides a suitable introduction to the study. Consider whether the manuscript establishes the research context and presents the problem being investigated.

  1. Structure and Strength of Argument

Examine the organization of the manuscript and the logical development of its arguments. Indicate the strength of the argument using one of the following ratings:

  • Very Good
  • Good
  • Average
  • Poor
  • Very Poor
  1. Mechanical Accuracy

Assess the manuscript’s use of language, including:

  • Grammar and sentence construction.
  • Punctuation.
  • Spelling.
  • Appropriate use of words.
  • Clarity and readability.

Reviewers should identify language problems that affect the clarity or understanding of the research.

  1. Comments on Specific Sections

The review form requires comments on the following aspects:

  • General assessment of the manuscript.
  • Adequacy of the theoretical and empirical literature.
  • Soundness of the research methodology.
  • Whether the results and supporting evidence justify the conclusions and recommendations.
  • Quality of the discussion and interpretation of findings.
  • Relevance and adequacy of policy suggestions, where applicable.
  • Adequacy and accuracy of the bibliography and references.
  • Any other issues requiring the attention of the authors or editorial team.

Comments should identify specific weaknesses and, where possible, explain how they can be addressed.

Manuscript Rating

Reviewers are required to rate the manuscript using the four-point scale provided in the official review form.

Rating

Description

1

Excellent

2

Good

3

Fair

4

Poor

The ratings should cover the following criteria:

  • Completeness and accuracy of figures and tables.
  • Contribution to knowledge.
  • Novelty of ideas and concepts.
  • Technical quality.
  • Clarity of presentation.
  • Depth of research.

Reviewers should select the rating that best reflects the manuscript’s performance under each criterion.

Recommendation on the Manuscript

At the end of the assessment, reviewers should select one of the recommendations provided in the official review form:

  • Accept as is: The manuscript meets the journal’s requirements and is suitable for publication without further substantive corrections.
  • Requires Minor Corrections: The manuscript is generally satisfactory but needs limited corrections or clarifications.
  • Requires Moderate Revision: The manuscript requires further improvements in specific areas before it can be considered for publication.
  • Requires Major Revision: Substantial changes are necessary before the manuscript can be reconsidered.
  • Reject on Grounds of: The manuscript has significant weaknesses that make it unsuitable for publication. The reviewer must clearly state the reasons for the recommendation.
  • Other Comments: Additional observations or recommendations relevant to the editorial assessment.

The recommendation should be consistent with the reviewer’s comments and ratings.

Quality of Review Reports

Review reports should be clear, professional, and constructive. The purpose of the review is to help the editor reach an informed decision and, where appropriate, assist authors in improving their manuscripts.

Reviewers should:

  • Identify the major strengths and weaknesses of the manuscript.
  • Explain the academic or methodological basis for their observations.
  • Distinguish between issues requiring substantial revision and minor corrections.
  • Provide specific suggestions where improvements are necessary.
  • Avoid personal remarks, offensive language, or comments unrelated to the academic quality of the work.

General statements such as “the paper is weak” or “the methodology is inadequate” should be supported with clear explanations.

Research Integrity and Ethical Concerns

Reviewers should notify the handling editor if they identify possible ethical or research integrity concerns, including:

  • Plagiarism or unattributed use of published material.
  • Duplicate or redundant publication.
  • Fabrication or falsification of research data.
  • Inappropriate authorship practices.
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest.
  • Questionable research procedures or ethical concerns.
  • Unacknowledged use of sources or materials.

Reviewers should not contact authors directly or conduct independent investigations into suspected misconduct. Such concerns should be reported confidentially to the handling editor for appropriate consideration.

Independence and Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers must provide impartial assessments and disclose any circumstances that could compromise their independence.

A reviewer should decline an assignment where a close personal relationship, institutional connection, professional rivalry, financial interest, or other competing interest could influence the assessment.

If a potential conflict becomes apparent after accepting an assignment, the reviewer should notify the editorial office immediately.

Submission of Review Reports

Reviewers should complete and return the official Manuscript Reviewer’s Comments Form within the period specified in the review invitation.

The completed form should provide:

  • An assessment of the manuscript under the specified criteria.
  • Comments on relevant sections of the manuscript.
  • Ratings for the stated assessment areas.
  • A clear publication recommendation.
  • Additional confidential observations for the editor, where necessary.

Reviewers should ensure that their reports are sufficiently detailed to support the editorial decision.

Contact Information

For enquiries relating to review assignments, submission of review reports or other editorial matters, reviewers may contact:

The Editorial Office
African Journal of Economic Transformation and Development (AJETD)
African Academic Imprint Press (AAIMP), Nigeria
Email: ajetdpress@gmail.com


Nature is a life inspiration

Floreo – sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis iste natus error sit voluptatem accusantium doloremque laudantium, totam rem aperiam, eaque ipsa quae ab illo inventore veritatis et quasi architecto beatae vitae dicta sunt explicabo.

Peter Stanton, CEO

Meet

Our Team

Petra Matinson

Designer & Florist

Alicia Jackson

sales manager

Petter Stanton

delivery & care

OBJECTIVES

OUR OBJECTIVES

Happy Clients
0
Products
0
Ratings
0

Our Newsletter

Enter your email address to be updated with fresh news

Receive emails updates and hot offers